When all of the talk about this box or that box taking over your living room and being the mother of all multimedia got started, I could only greet with yawns of indifference at best. I really didn’t want everything ending up in one box (including my PC), and hooked up to the living room TV. Afterall, I’ve got some things on the PC that need to just stay there…heh heh…like all of my code, yeah, that’s right… But I keep an open mind, and like to at least try new things before passing judgment.
I have my TiVo box to thank for my latest discoveries because the 2.5.1 update to TiVo Desktop got me exploring new ways to stream video on my PC to the TV in the living room. Well, I’ve not been over impressed, actually, not impressed at all with TiVo Desktop. TiVo Desktop feels clunky and lacks a number of features unless you spend $25 for the plus version. I found it particularly annoying that the 2.5.1 update seems to imply that you can stream a bunch of new formats, including wmv, in the free version. I wasted a lot of time before discovering that I would need the plus version for that. Even if it was included, I have a series two TiVo which is so underpowered that you really have to wait for the whole thing to download to avoid stop and go playback. TiVo is good enough for its main job as a personal DVR, but really sucks for the added on multimedia extras.
So in comes my Xbox 360. The most recent Xbox Live Update included support for a number of additional media formats and since I’d not used it for anything but games, I decided to see if it could easily get my PC bound media playing on the big screen of the living room TV (sadly, still SD) and saving me the time and trouble of burning DVDs.
I was not disappointed. Right now it plays everything I have except a couple of oddball DivX encoded videos (plays other DivX okay) and, of course, music from the iTunes store. I was so happy with it that I’ve not touched any games on it for some time, instead using the time to give my PC media a living room airing out so to speak. No more lengthy transcoding! Yay!
Bottom line, TiVo had better watch its back. Outside of being a DVR, my 360 did everything better than my TiVo. If DVR functions are added plus a comparable TV scheduling service, getting the 120GB hard disk for the 360 might be looking pretty good. TiVo is already in partnerships to add their software and service to 3rd party cable boxes. If they’re smart, they’ll also be exploring ways to get on the Xbox 360 and Playstation 3 because after what I’ve seen, the multimedia functions of these powerful games consoles will eat them alive. If these boxes become powerful DVRs as well, it could be game over for TiVo.